After Years of Lost Opportunities, Serbia Must Not Miss This New Chance for Reform and EU Accession

The European Commission’s latest annual report on Serbia points to continued overall stagnation in the reform process, with backsliding recorded in several areas - the worst assessment to date. The change of government following the 25 October elections marks a new chapter in Serbia’s EU accession process and offers an opportunity to accelerate reforms, as strengthening the rule of law and democracy is a key priority of the incoming government. 

The European Commission continues to identify some degree of “progress” in most areas of its annual Report, even when this is limited to purely formal aspects or relatively minor changes. For the first time, backsliding has been recorded in more than one area: public administration reform and freedom of expression, both under Cluster 1 (Fundamentals), as well as Chapter 30 - External Relations and Chapter 26 - Education and Culture. Even in Chapters 25 and 26, which are generally uncontroversial and provisionally closed immediately after being opened, the outgoing government has managed to undermine previous achievements through increased pressure on academia and the education sector, which have emerged as driving forces behind the wave of public protests.

Of particular concern is the prolonged stagnation in the rule of law. No progress has been recorded in Chapter 23 as a whole for two consecutive years, and the same applies to the functioning of the judiciary, while freedom of expression has continued to backslide since 2025. Chapter 24 received a somewhat more favourable assessment, but has recorded only limited progress for two consecutive years, as has its sub-area of the fight against organised crime. This indicates that no substantial advances have been made in the other key chapter of Cluster 1 either.

 

After Years of Lost Opportunities, Serbia Must Not Miss This New Chance for Reform and EU Accession

 

Looking Back: Key Problems Persist and Deepen

A similar assessment of the problems in critical areas such as the separation of powers, media freedom, the judiciary and the fight against corruption is presented in the Rule of Law Report, which the European Commission has also been preparing for Serbia for the past three years and publishing each summer. Both reports paint a troubling picture of Serbia: political pressure on the judiciary and prosecution service has increased significantly, while safeguards for prosecutorial autonomy and judicial independence have been partly weakened. The police still lack sufficient operational autonomy from political interference by the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Meanwhile, efforts to combat corruption continue to fall short of delivering convincing results.

Particularly alarming is the continued erosion of media freedom and civic space. Political and economic influence over the media is identified as a serious problem, the safety of journalists has deteriorated further, civil society faces growing pressure and intimidation, and reported cases of excessive use of force against protesters have largely gone unpunished. Taken together, the reports point not merely to stalled reforms, but to deepening problems within the very institutions responsible for safeguarding the separation of powers, ensuring accountability and protecting fundamental rights.

Looking Ahead: The Incoming Government Must Deliver Meaningful, Far-Reaching Reforms

This European Commission Report marks the end of the Serbian Progressive Party’s time in power. The Student List won the 25 October elections on a promise to return the captured state to its citizens - a state in which institutions serve the public interest and everyone is equal before the law. The reforms ahead have secured a convincing electoral mandate. Crucially, the demand for change is genuine and has emerged from the grassroots, rooted in citizens’ everyday experiences. It has not been imposed by the European Union, although it is hardly surprising that the priorities identified by citizens and Brussels largely converge.

The prEUgovor coalition will continue to monitor reforms under Cluster 1 - Fundamentals, expecting the incoming government to overcome the obstacles and lack of political will that have long prevented meaningful progress on the rule of law. This would finally allow Serbia to seize the renewed opportunity for EU enlargement that emerged following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

Beyond Cluster 1, where the priorities of the incoming government and Brussels largely align, Serbia faces other sensitive and potentially contentious negotiating chapters that could impede further progress. These include Chapter 31 (Foreign, Security and Defence Policy), which requires Serbia to align with EU positions, including those concerning Russia, and Chapter 35 (Other Issues), which covers the normalisation of relations with Pristina. At this critical juncture, the European Commission and the Council of the EU would be well advised not to make progress on these chapters an immediate condition for advancing accession negotiations. Doing so could deepen Euroscepticism in a country facing an ambitious and demanding agenda of domestic reforms.

 

After Years of Lost Opportunities, Serbia Must Not Miss This New Chance for Reform and EU Accession

 

Serbia is poised to open Cluster 3, for which it is already technically prepared - even more so than for some of the clusters opened to date (see chart above). However, persistent shortcomings in the rule of law have held back progress in accession negotiations. The prEUgovor coalition also expects the implementation of priority measures under the Reform Agenda, particularly those relating to Cluster 1, which would unlock further disbursements under the Growth Plan for Serbia. Although deadlines for many of these measures have already passed, the European Commission has so far allowed a grace period to prevent the permanent loss of allocated funds.

Serbia has thus lost valuable time in which it could have moved closer to EU membership alongside Montenegro, with which it once led the accession process. Meanwhile, Albania has overtaken Serbia both in the number of negotiating chapters opened and in its overall level of preparedness for membership. While Montenegro and Albania are now seen as the frontrunners, Serbia has, for the second consecutive year, been grouped with Georgia and Türkiye, countries whose accession processes have been marked by a lack of commitment and backsliding. As the chart below illustrates, Serbia remains relatively close to Albania in terms of overall preparedness, but the gap is considerably wider in Cluster 1, particularly in Chapters 23 and 24, which concern the rule of law.

At the same time, the experiences of Montenegro and Albania demonstrate what can be achieved in a relatively short period when the necessary political will exists. The prEUgovor coalition, however, has consistently emphasised the quality and substance of reforms over the speed of the accession process.

 

After Years of Lost Opportunities, Serbia Must Not Miss This New Chance for Reform and EU Accession

Read on for insights from prEUgovor coalition members on the key areas they regularly monitor.

 

Fight Against Corruption: Piecemeal Legislative Improvements Amid Deteriorating Practice

For the third consecutive year, the European Commission’s annual report has assessed Serbia as having made limited progress in the fight against corruption, even though developments on the ground suggest not only a lack of progress but significant backsliding. These assessments appear to rely primarily on formal criteria, whereby even minor improvements are rewarded with a more favourable rating, regardless of setbacks in other areas or the persistent lack of progress on the most pressing issues. International assessments of perceived corruption paint a different picture: according to the Corruption Perceptions Index, Serbia has continued to decline, recording its worst score in two decades.

The Commission’s recommendations focus on strengthening the track record in combating corruption, fully implementing GRECO recommendations and putting anti-corruption strategic documents into practice. Yet the Commission’s own report indicates backsliding in the first of these areas. The implementation of “some recommendations” is described as “a step in the right direction”, while the limited progress identified relates almost exclusively to legislative amendments.

In particular, the report notes the adoption of amendments to the Law on Financing Political Activities, the Law on Prevention of Corruption and the Law on Lobbying, which address only some of the ODIHR and GRECO recommendations, before moving directly to the need to monitor their implementation. However, it fails to acknowledge that these amendments were adopted through a process that left very little room for meaningful improvements to the legislation.

Anti-Corruption Strategies Lack Ambition - and Remain Largely Unimplemented

Regarding the strategic framework for combating corruption, which has received considerable attention in previous reports, the focus has shifted from adopting strategic documents - the Strategy and its accompanying action plans - to their implementation. However, the Commission’s report incorrectly attributes the poor implementation of the action plan to the absence of a coordination body. As the report itself acknowledges, as many as 80% of the measures from previous action plans have been carried over into the Action Plan for 2026-2028. Transparency Serbia has repeatedly warned that the measures envisaged under these strategic documents lack ambition and would fail to address the most pressing challenges in combating corruption, even if fully implemented.

The outgoing government’s lack of genuine commitment to tackling corruption is perhaps best illustrated by the European Commission’s repeated calls over the years for the Government to cooperate with a body it established itself - the Anti-Corruption Council. Such cooperation requires neither additional resources nor new mechanisms, but simply the political will to act.

The report notes that Serbia has implemented just three of the 24 recommendations from GRECO’s fifth evaluation round, describing this as a step in the right direction, despite the fact that all recommendations were due to be implemented by the end of 2023. Moreover, work has not even begun on several key recommendations, particularly those concerning the immunity of government members, integrity checks for senior executive officials before taking office, and extending the jurisdiction of the Prosecutor’s Office for Organised Crime (TOK) to cases involving the criminal liability of the President of the Republic.

Lack of Transparency in Public Procurement Draws Public and European Commission Scrutiny

The Commission’s report mentions whistleblowers only in the context of exposing contracts and public procurement practices, and the need to align the legislative framework with EU standards. However, recent developments following the political changes in Serbia point to renewed public willingness to report suspected corruption, highlighting the need to strengthen whistleblower protection in practice and, in particular, to ensure effective follow-up on their reports.

The report identifies public procurement as an area particularly vulnerable to corruption, noting that numerous contracts are awarded under special laws or intergovernmental agreements that circumvent the rules established by the Public Procurement Law. It explicitly refers to the special law governing EXPO and an amendment to the special law on the Morava Corridor, which enabled the project to be extended to an additional section. Similarly, the Commission notes that the public call for the construction of the Djerdap 3 hydropower project restricted competition.

According to the Commission, transparency in projects implemented under intergovernmental agreements has “increased”, but remains “insufficient”. Notably, this issue is also addressed under the Reform Agenda, where the Commission has preliminarily assessed the measure concerning the “publication of contracts” as fulfilled.

The prEUgovor coalition recalls that the Constitutional Court has yet to examine the initiative challenging the constitutionality of the special EXPO law. Meanwhile, recently published findings reveal that competition in procurement procedures conducted under this law is significantly weaker than in ordinary public procurement. This can partly be attributed to the complete absence of legal remedies in these procedures, even in cases where there are clear indications of bid rigging.

Fundamental Rights: Vulnerable Groups Still Left Behind

This year, the European Commission largely reiterates its previous assessments and recommendations, underscoring the lack of meaningful and sustainable progress in protecting fundamental rights. The central challenge remains the gap between the adoption of legislation and strategic documents and their implementation, compounded by inadequate institutional safeguards, insufficient financial and human resources, and limited access to support services. The Commission’s findings closely reflect the concerns raised in the May 2026 edition and earlier editions of the Alarm Report. They also confirm that the problem lies not in a failure to identify priorities, but in the lack of political and institutional accountability for putting them into practice.

The Commission highlights the inadequate enforcement of anti-discrimination legislation, backsliding on gender equality, and the suspension of the relevant law. Women from marginalised groups remain particularly vulnerable to multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination. Violence against women and domestic violence remain widespread, while women participating in protests face disproportionate levels of violence and intimidation. Despite repeated recommendations to align legislation with international standards, including by revising the legal definitions of rape and sexual harassment, key measures remain unimplemented. The Strategy for Combating Violence against Women has been extended until 2027, with changes to its indicators introduced without public consultation, while the accompanying action plan has yet to be adopted. Particularly alarming is the growing number of women killed after previously reporting abuse, alongside chronic underfunding and uneven access to specialised support services, most of which are provided by civil society organisations.

The Commission reiterates its calls for stronger legislation and more effective protection of fundamental rights. In the area of child’s rights, key gaps persist, including the absence of a ban on corporal punishment in the home and child marriage, inadequate protection of children who have experienced violence, and serious violations of children’s rights in residential institutions, particularly those affecting children with disabilities. The Commission also raises concerns over the authorities’ unjustified questioning of children’s participation in protests. For persons with disabilities, major challenges include persistent barriers to accessibility, slow progress on deinstitutionalisation, violence against women in residential institutions, and the urgent need to reform the legal framework governing deprivation of legal capacity to safeguard their rights. LGBTIQ+ persons continue to face discrimination, hate speech and violence, without adequate institutional protection or legal recognition of same-sex partnerships.

The alignment of criminal legislation with EU standards continues to lag behind, as does the adoption of a strategy on victims’ and witnesses’ rights and the establishment of a national victim support service. Civil society organisations continue to provide most specialised support services without stable funding. Access to justice remains particularly difficult for women experiencing gender-based violence and discrimination, while amendments to the Law on Free Legal Aid have yet to be adopted.

Chapter 24: Limited Normative Progress, Regression in Practice

Some progress under Chapter 24 was achieved through the adoption of legislation and strategic documents on combating human trafficking, arms trafficking and violent extremism. These measures were also commitments under Serbia’s 2024 Reform Agenda, although their implementation came well beyond the agreed deadlines.

In the critical areas of police reform and the fight against organised crime, however, there was no legislative progress, while the situation on the ground deteriorated. The European Commission reiterates its call to ensure the police’s operational autonomy from the Ministry of Internal Affairs and strengthen cooperation between the police and prosecution service. The April 2026 draft Law on Internal Affairs failed to address these priorities and was not adopted even within the extended deadline. With the change of government, the draft is expected to be shelved - arguably the best outcome after several deeply flawed versions.

The Commission is considerably more explicit than before in its criticism of the involvement of security services in criminal investigations, calling on Serbia to gradually phase out their role in investigating serious and organised crime. This reform has seen virtually no progress since the adoption of the Chapter 24 Action Plan a decade ago. Likewise, the operational plan on financial investigations and confiscation of illegally acquired assets, drafted in 2025, remains unfinished. These long-overdue reforms are expected to feature prominently on the incoming government’s agenda and are already the subject of intense public debate.

The report notes that the Prosecutor’s Office for Organised Crime (TOK) faces mounting pressure and obstacles, while investigations into politically sensitive cases, such as the Novi Sad railway station canopy collapse, remain unfinished. Serbia also continues to lack a solid track record of investigations, indictments and final convictions in organised crime and high-level corruption cases. Particular attention is given to the damaging effects of the so-called Mrdić laws on the TOK and the Special Prosecutor’s Office for High-Tech Crime, which has been merged into the Higher Public Prosecutor’s Office in Belgrade.

The Commission’s broadly positive assessment of migration management fails to adequately reflect shifting migration patterns, weaknesses in monitoring and controlling foreigners’ entry and stay, the continued activity of violent smuggling networks, and challenges associated with labour migration, including preventing secondary movements and protecting migrants from exploitation. Increased staffing at the Asylum Office, more interviews and fewer pending cases do not necessarily translate into better or timelier decisions. Meanwhile, gaps in child protection and disruptions to legal aid, psychosocial support, interpretation and cultural mediation services provided by civil society raise serious concerns about the system’s effectiveness and sustainability. The recommendation to align with the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum should be translated into clear priorities and an assessment of its implications for Serbia, particularly as the Pact’s effectiveness has yet to be comprehensively evaluated even within the EU. Serbia’s dual position as an EU candidate and a third country under certain mechanisms must also be taken into account.

The report’s more critical and realistic assessment of the fight against human trafficking in Serbia is much welcome. Crucially, it acknowledges that civil society organisations shoulder most of the responsibility for victim protection and support, despite lacking adequate and sustainable funding. The finding that strategic documents have yet to produce tangible results confirms that progress has largely remained formal rather than substantive. Serbia adopted a new Law on the Prevention and Suppression of Human Trafficking and Protection of Victims in April 2026, followed by amendments to the Criminal Code in July 2026 that effectively criminalised arms trafficking. However, legislative and strategic advances must be matched by concrete results in prosecuting perpetrators and ensuring effective protection for victims.